Sunnydale After Dark
Summary: A drabble collection exploring various scenarios of Buffy and Spike comprehending, showing or admitting their love for each other.
Banner Art By: simmony
Categories: Drabbles, Sunnydale After Dark Exclusive
Characters: Buffy, Spike, Ensemble
Genres: Angst, Fluffy, HEA/HFN, Romance
Warnings: (Click Here To Reveal) Adult Language, Character Death, Sexual Situations
Completed: Yes Chapters: 30
Word count: 3,000 Hit Count: 2,387 ePub Downloads: 8
Published: 03/01/24 Updated: 03/30/24


Print or Download Story: Printer Microsoft Word ePub eBook

Share Story:

View All Chapters

Story Notes: I am turning into a big sap this month, which is maybe the exact opposite of my Spooky September fic. I HAVE LAYERS, okay?
Some of these slot into universes / AUs I've written before, some of which might be fics not on SAD yet (because I suck at crossposting) or WIPs. Some drabbles may be stories all on their own. All can be read without the context of the fic that inspired them. I will note when there's a specific version of Spuffy I had in mind while writing, for funsies. 
The title is a Tom Rosenthal song of the same name which I fell in love with recently and listened to on repeat when I was trying to come up with a theme for my drabbles. It helped!


Disclaimer: All publicly recognizable characters, settings, etc. are the property of their respective owners. The original characters and plot are the property of the author. The author is in no way associated with the owners, creators, or producers of any media franchise. No copyright infringement is intended.

1. Already Family by simmony - Likes: 25 Comments: 43 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 198 Published: 03/01/24

Prompt: Fortune Cookie Epiphany

I imagine this taking place in the TAWG universe, about 1 1/2 years after the fic's conclusion / in the first half of what would be season 5. But it's totally not necessary to have read that fic, especially since I haven't even finished it yet. 

2. Show Don't Tell by simmony - Likes: 25 Comments: 38 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 120 Published: 03/02/24

Prompt: Lights Out

This isn't set in any specific universe, but I'm pretty sure I did just give myself cavities. 

3. Soul Comfort by simmony - Likes: 23 Comments: 35 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 105 Published: 03/03/24

Prompt: Cooking Together

So last year, I wrote this funny little (not yet cross-posted) story about Buffy and Spike accidentally binding their souls together (oops!). As a result, they can feel each other's emotions. That can be hella annoying, but it can also be a comfort, which I attempted to show here. Buffy isn't really cooking alone. This drabble is set a decade after the events of Binding Effects.

4. Confidant In The Dark by simmony - Likes: 21 Comments: 34 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 100 Published: 03/04/24

Prompt: Horrible Day

I had a lot of ideas for this prompt so I went with the one most unlike the drabbles I've already written. Set in canon season six, sometime before they start sleeping together.

5. Battle Night by simmony - Likes: 24 Comments: 28 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 100 Published: 03/05/24

Prompt: Rock Concert TIckets

Oh my gosh, this prompt sent me into a research frenzy of 2012 concert tours. The concerts Buffy and Spike attend are the One Direction Up All Night Tour (which played the Gibson Amphitheatre in Los Angeles on June 16th) and the The Killers Battle Born World Tour (which played THE SAME VENUE on December 9th of that year). None of this is necessary knowledge for the enjoyment of this drabble BUT I WANT TO SHOW I DID THE WORK HERE, OKAY?

Not set in any particular universe. Just plain old established relationship Spuffy.

6. Nothing Compares To by simmony - Likes: 21 Comments: 24 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 96 Published: 03/06/24

Prompt: Orange

Set mid-story in a WIP I'm writing that has Spuffy caught in a murder time loop (them killing each other resets the loop). Spike is falling in love, because of course he is.

7. You're Not Allowed by simmony - Likes: 22 Comments: 28 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 92 Published: 03/07/24

Prompt: Spilling

I'm sorry about this, really I am. I don't know why my mind went there, other than I didn't want to do smut (yet?). Set somewhere in the future, established Spuffy, mid-battle.

8. Flowers by simmony - Likes: 24 Comments: 25 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 78 Published: 03/08/24

Prompt: Dirty Pretty Things

This drabble was totally inspired by a fic I read that has Spike tending to Buffy's plants and is, if I remember correctly, also set after season 6. Canon season 7, because I love the tentative Spuffy in that season endlessly.

9. Northern Lights by simmony - Likes: 19 Comments: 27 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 100 Published: 03/09/24

Prompt: Midnight Revelations

I loved this prompt so much. It gave me an excuse to write a scene for a fic I've been outlining (or slacking on outlining lol). It's a post-series reunion story which basically Spuffy-fies this cheesy German TV drama about wedding planners working on a cruise ship. Spike retired from demon fighting and trying to get Buffy back to buy a ship and found this demon-themed wedding planning company. Buffy gets thrown in the mix when she applies to sub for a wedding planner who has fallen ill—under a false name, of course—to investigate if there are actual, real demons on this weird cruise liner they've heard rumblings about. BOOM, run-in with Spike. Shenanigans ensue. 

10. Wake-Up Call by simmony - Likes: 20 Comments: 19 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 79 Published: 03/10/24

Prompt: Desperate For Attention

I'm not sure where this came from. It was the first idea I had this morning and wouldn't leave me alone even after I told it to shush. All that to say I empathize with Buffy in this drabble, lol. Established Spuffy, whenever, wherever, take your pick!
(I feel like I've read at least one story that named their daughter Violet, but I liked the name and didn't have time to check before my brunch plans. If it was you, hi! Hope you're not upset I sorta maybe stole the name. One of my new gymnasts is called Violet, that's more than likely why it popped into my head.)

11. He's Just Ken by simmony - Likes: 17 Comments: 19 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 91 Published: 03/11/24

Prompt: In Three Long Strides

Circling back to the rock concert tickets chapter in this one, lol. I was frustrated about only having ideas I wasn't excited about for this prompt until Ryan Gosling's Academy Awards performance of I'm Just Ken popped up in my YouTube feed. I'm sure this scenario has been done before, but not by me! Again, you can imagine this being the same version of Spuffy rocking out at a One Direction concert twelve years prior.

12. Undercover Mission by simmony - Likes: 17 Comments: 17 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 77 Published: 03/12/24

Prompt: Bright Red Confetti

We're staying R-rated for now, kids. More recently established relationship Spuffy, I would say. First year. No particular fic in mind. I'm running wild!

13. Moving Day by simmony - Likes: 14 Comments: 19 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 70 Published: 03/13/24

Prompt: Heavy Metal

I dislike heavy metal music so I went non-literal here, lol. Sorry not sorry. Late today because I'm at a work conference and couldn't write this until just now. No particular universe. I can't picture Spike owning a normal suitcase or (to a lesser degree) using moving boxes, haha.

14. Change Of Mind by simmony - Likes: 14 Comments: 15 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 61 Published: 03/14/24

Prompt: Spike Ignoring Buffy

Once again taking place in my (unpublished, unfinished) murder loop fic. Spike falling in love from the other perspective, through actions instead of words.

15. Un-Undead by simmony - Likes: 16 Comments: 15 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 71 Published: 03/15/24

Prompt: Goes Right Through

Set in an alternate universe Post-Chosen. Spike survived the battle on the Hellmouth. They're staying the night at the Hyperion. I was going to spend time justifying this not technically being a moment centered around their love for each other, but they are so obviously in love by the end of the series I'm proclaiming the subtext suffices to fit my theme.

16. Not Doing That by simmony - Likes: 14 Comments: 22 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 74 Published: 03/16/24

Prompt: Petty Argument/Fight

Set during Something Blue (beloved episode). Can talk of murdering children be petty? You tell me, lol.

17. To Great Lengths by simmony - Likes: 15 Comments: 21 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 84 Published: 03/17/24

Prompt: The Rhyme For Orange

To whoever submitted this prompt, I hate you, LOL (kidding, only love). I spent my morning frantically googling only to end up with a literal interpretation after all. 

18. Tunnel Vision by simmony - Likes: 16 Comments: 17 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 61 Published: 03/18/24

Prompt: Bad Weather

Set in S6 during their affair (or whatever you want to call it, Buffy doesn't know either). 

19. Catch by simmony - Likes: 14 Comments: 15 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 76 Published: 03/19/24

Prompt: Weapon Tossing (as a love language)

I know a lot of people (including me) were worried about poor Spike dying in chapter seven, so I decided to write this. I wasn't originally going to connect any chapters but oh well, haha.

20. Something Old by simmony - Likes: 16 Comments: 17 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 50 Published: 03/20/24

Prompt: I. Would. Not.

Wrote this in a panic before a full work day, haha. Set in an established relationship future of your choosing.

21. Unearthing by simmony - Likes: 13 Comments: 16 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 58 Published: 03/21/24

Prompt: Buffy Tells Spike

I've never written anything for that fade to black scene in Chosen, so here you go. Forget about the later canon events for this one, haha. Remember I’m not killing Spike. He’ll totally survive the Hellmouth.

22. Watchman by simmony - Likes: 14 Comments: 15 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 51 Published: 03/22/24

Prompt: Ghost

I'm sorry. But I technically didn't kill Spike here either. He's...already dead. Um...again, sorry. Set sometime during Wraith. Context for those who haven’t read Wraith: Spike died in the fight against Glory and Buffy is grieving his loss while also seeing him in her dreams (where he is corporeal) and in the waking world (where he isn’t ).

23. Stakeout Serenade by simmony - Likes: 14 Comments: 13 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 61 Published: 03/23/24

Prompt: You Do Something To Me

I struggled with this one, partially because of non-writerly offline life reasons. Still not fully content with this drabble, but if it took me until drabble 23 to get this feeling, that's an achievement of its own in my book, haha. Borrowing lines from "You Do Something To Me" by Paul Weller. Set during the episode Crush. 

24. No Second Thoughts by simmony - Likes: 13 Comments: 15 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 69 Published: 03/24/24

Prompt: Not What It Looks Like

This one was fun, haha. Set sometime post-Destiny (AtS). Also feel free to join me in pretending Spike didn't go off to sleep with Harmony as soon as he was corporeal again. 

25. Confrontation by simmony - Likes: 13 Comments: 15 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 59 Published: 03/25/24

Prompt: Remember Me

So this one takes place sometime after the conclusion of a fic I have fully written but only posted the first chapter of (and only over on EF) so far because it still needs to be beta'ed. Overture (that mostly unpublished fic) is an AU season one story set in 2009/2010 that sees Buffy being Called in a world where the existence of demons is public knowledge and the Slayer is more of a keeper of the peace than someone who, well, slays demons. Spike is working for/enslaved by the Council and helps train her for this new role she's expected to play but has not been prepared for one bit, because no one expected the last Slayer to die so young (she died of cancer). Anyway, Buffy and Spike develop somewhat of a friendship despite Spike, who was best friends with the late Slayer, initially not wanting anything to do with her. And our Buffy, 18 years old and all alone in a new town surrounded by new everything, develops a serious crush on her vampire training partner. Cue this scene, set approximately six months after their first meeting. They've been through some stuff together but haven't addressed the elephant in the room. Until the night before. 

26. Throw The Fear by simmony - Likes: 14 Comments: 15 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 50 Published: 03/26/24

Prompt: Math

I was not going to write about actual math, friends. Nuh-uh. 

27. It's All Coming Down by simmony - Likes: 12 Comments: 18 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 49 Published: 03/27/24

Prompt: Bad-Aid

This one got dark, oops. Added a character death warning for Spike's canon death. Set post-Chosen. There's love in the pain of missing someone?

28. Too Long by simmony - Likes: 14 Comments: 17 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 51 Published: 03/28/24

Prompt: Storytelling

As my apology for yesterday's grief fest, please accept this drabble closest to a sex scene as I'm likely to write for this event. 

29. Milk and Cookies by simmony - Likes: 13 Comments: 14 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 73 Published: 03/29/24

Prompt: Costumy Party

What would a drabble event be without me calling back to another drabble event I participated in? Set shortly after the last chapter of To Still Be Wanting You (which I wrote for EF's Drabblemania last July). All you need to know is that Buffy and Spike have been back together for about half a year, and that they're at a costume party (HOW CONVENIENT, RIGHT?) dressed up as cookies and a milkman. 

30. Partners In Everything by simmony - Likes: 12 Comments: 18 Word Count: 100 Hit Count: 83 Published: 03/30/24

Prompt: Fire

This somehow ended up slotting into my Soulbound universe (for which I have yet to write more than one fic lol). But you don't need to know the specifics of it to read the drabble.