Sunnydale After Dark
Not So Vanilla by MaggieLaFey
Summary:  
rn
In an alternate universe where Spike is a single vampire and Buffy is just a (not-so-)vanilla human, things go pretty smutty as soon as they meet.
rn
It just gets pervier from there.
rn
The first story is told in drabbles, the following ones in longform oneshots.
Banner Art By: SomeKindOfADeviant
Categories: Alternate Universe
Characters: Buffy, Spike, Faith Lehane, Willow
Genres: Erotica, Established Relationship, Porn w/o Plot, Threesome
Warnings: Adult Language, Blood Play, Buffy/Other (Temp), Dubious Consent, Fetish, Sexual Situations, Taboo, Threesome(s), Violence
Challenges: None
Parent Series: None
Stories: 6
Series Type: Closed

Vanilla and Spice by MaggieLaFey [Adult Only] Likes: 415 Comments: 66
Summary: Buffy is an average girl trying to take a picture in a photo booth, when a not-so-average bleached guy rushes in, crowding her inside.
He’s hot and distracting enough that she ignores the smoke coming off him.
That she ignores all signals, really, until she’s way too deep to even consider getting out.
Super hot banner by the amazing Lady Emma!
Series: Not So Vanilla
Categories: Alternate Universe, Drabbles
Characters: Buffy, Spike
Genres: Erotica, HEA/HFN, Lighthearted, Porn w/o Plot, Romance
Warnings: (Click Here To Reveal) Adult Language, Blood Play, Dubious Consent, Fetish, Sexual Situations, Violence
Completed: Yes Chapters: 77 Table of Contents
Word count: 7,700 Hit Count: 10,821 ePub Downloads: 23
Published: 08/03/23 Updated: 08/09/23
Sharing is Fun! by MaggieLaFey [Adult Only] Likes: 14 Comments: 14
Summary: A sequel to Vanilla and Spice: AU where vamp Spike “adopts” (not-so) vanilla human Buffy as his little pet. Kinda literally.
He’s accepted to only do catch and release for her, but she’s gonna help him stay interested while he does.
Enter Faith.
Series: Not So Vanilla
Categories: Alternate Universe
Characters: Buffy, Spike, Faith Lehane
Genres: Erotica, Established Relationship, Porn w/o Plot, Threesome
Warnings: (Click Here To Reveal) Adult Language, Blood Play, Buffy/Other (Temp), Dubious Consent, Fetish, Sexual Situations, Spike/Other (Temp), Taboo, Threesome(s), Violence
Completed: Yes Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Word count: 3,191 Hit Count: 423 ePub Downloads: 12
Published: 08/13/23 Updated: 08/13/23
Outside Help by MaggieLaFey [Adult Only] Likes: 10 Comments: 12
Summary: A sequel to Sharing Is Fun, but you only need to know that (vanilla human) Buffy’s been naughty, and (vamp) Spike, ever the good pet owner, is going to punish her.
For once, he’s gonna ask for outside help to do it… and Buffy won’t be able to say no.
Incredible banner by the incomparable loveisntbrains!
Series: Not So Vanilla
Categories: Alternate Universe
Characters: Buffy, Spike, Willow
Genres: Alternate Reality, Erotica, Established Relationship, Porn w/o Plot, Threesome
Warnings: (Click Here To Reveal) Adult Language, Buffy/Other (Temp), Dubious Consent, Fetish, Sexual Situations, Taboo, Threesome(s), Violence
Completed: Yes Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Word count: 6,915 Hit Count: 552 ePub Downloads: 10
Published: 08/29/23 Updated: 08/29/23
Out For A Walk... Bitch by MaggieLaFey [Adult Only] Likes: 88 Comments: 98
Summary: When Spike decides to take his bitch girl out for a walk, he wants to spice it up. It's not like Buffy's gonna say no to him, is it? Not even when he means to chase her through a graveyard in the middle of the night.
If he thinks this is gonna faze her, he's got another thing coming.
(Or does she?)
AMAZING banner by the fabulous DeathTheKat!
Series: Not So Vanilla
Beta: Julikobold
Banner Art By: DeathTheKat
Categories: Alternate Universe
Characters: Buffy, Spike, Oz
Genres: Erotica, Established Relationship, Porn w/o Plot, Threesome
Warnings: (Click Here To Reveal) Adult Language, Buffy/Other (Temp), Dubious Consent, Fetish, Sexual Situations, Taboo, Threesome(s), Violence, Warnings Added As Story Progresses
Completed: Yes Chapters: 20 Table of Contents
Word count: 11,000 Hit Count: 3,145 ePub Downloads: 22
Published: 09/29/23 Updated: 06/09/24
Feuer und Flamme by MaggieLaFey [Adult Only] Likes: 150 Comments: 168
Summary: Drabbles set in my puppy play AU, where Buffy is Spike's little puppy and they live kinkily ever after.
Series: Not So Vanilla
Banner Art By: Claire
Categories: Alternate Universe, Drabbles, Sunnydale After Dark Debut
Characters: Buffy, Spike, Other
Genres: Erotica, Established Relationship, Porn w/o Plot, Romance, Threesome
Warnings: (Click Here To Reveal) Adult Language, Blood Play, Buffy/Other (Temp), Dubious Consent, Fetish, Sexual Situations, Spike/Other (Temp), Taboo, Threesome(s), Violence, Warnings Added As Story Progresses
Completed: Yes Chapters: 31 Table of Contents
Word count: 3,100 Hit Count: 4,534 ePub Downloads: 15
Published: 03/06/24 Updated: 03/31/24
Ready For More by MaggieLaFey [Adult Only] Likes: 13 Comments: 7
Summary: Spike and Buffy enjoy some quiet time after a night spent with the family (his family).
And Spike won’t let any opportunity slip by without reminding Buffy just who’s leading the game, here.
Series: Not So Vanilla
, Series: Make Me Feel
A Gift For: Claire
Banner Art By: Claire
Categories: Alternate Universe, Sunnydale After Dark Debut
Characters: Buffy, Spike
Genres: Erotica, Established Relationship
Warnings: (Click Here To Reveal) Adult Language, Dubious Consent, Fetish, Sexual Situations, Taboo
Completed: Yes Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Word count: 1,389 Hit Count: 372 ePub Downloads: 10
Published: 06/09/24 Updated: 06/09/24